The American Silver Eagle: History, Designs and Versions

The American Silver Eagle is the official silver bullion coin of the United States and one of the most widely traded silver coins in the world. It is easy to recognise, easy to sell and backed by the US government for weight and purity. Its story also reflects a specific moment in American monetary history, when Washington decided to turn a stockpile of silver into coins for the public.

Origins: the Liberty Coin Act

In the 1980s the United States held a large strategic stockpile of silver. Congress decided to sell part of it through a new bullion coin, and the Liberty Coin Act, signed in 1985, authorised the program. The first Silver Eagles were struck in 1986, the same year the gold American Eagles were launched. For years the coins were made from silver bought from that stockpile; once it was exhausted, the Mint was authorised to buy silver on the market.

Specifications

The face value is symbolic: the silver is worth far more than one dollar. It does, however, make the coin legal tender, which is part of what distinguishes a government bullion coin from a private round.

The obverse: Walking Liberty

The front of the coin uses Adolph A. Weinman’s Walking Liberty design, originally created for the half dollar struck from 1916 to 1947. It shows Liberty striding toward the rising sun, draped in the American flag, carrying branches of laurel and oak. Many collectors consider it one of the finest US coin designs, and its revival on the Silver Eagle was a large part of the coin’s appeal.

The reverse: from heraldic eagle to landing eagle

From 1986 to mid-2021, the reverse showed a heraldic eagle with a shield, designed by John Mercanti. In 2021 the Mint introduced a new reverse showing an eagle preparing to land, carrying an oak branch, designed by Emily Damstra. Collectors call the two versions Type 1 and Type 2, and 2021 coins exist in both types. The redesign came with updated security features intended to make counterfeiting harder.

Bullion, proof and burnished versions

The Mint produces several versions of the coin, and they are priced very differently.

• Bullion coins are sold by the Mint to a network of authorised purchasers, which then resell to dealers and the public. They are struck for investors and carry the lowest premium.
• Proof coins are struck several times on polished blanks with special dies, giving mirror fields and frosted designs. They are sold directly to the public in presentation packaging and command a collector premium.
• Burnished (uncirculated) coins are struck on specially treated blanks and carry a mint mark. They sit between bullion and proof in price.

For a buyer whose aim is to hold silver, the bullion version usually offers the most metal for the money. Proof and burnished coins can be satisfying to own, but the extra premium is not guaranteed to come back on resale.

Mint marks and key dates

Bullion Silver Eagles have generally carried no mint mark, even though they have been struck at more than one facility over the years. Proof and burnished coins carry a letter showing where they were made. Some years and special issues have become sought-after, especially low-mintage proofs and anniversary sets. Collectors who pursue these should rely on reputable price guides rather than general bullion pricing.

Why the coin is so popular

The Silver Eagle combines a government guarantee, a well-loved design and wide recognition among dealers. Those features make it easy to resell, which partly explains why it often trades at a higher premium than comparable coins from other mints.

Whether that premium is worth paying depends on the buyer’s priorities. A comparison of coins, bars and pre-1965 coinage is in our article on silver coins vs silver bars and in the guide to 90% silver coin bags. Readers interested in what Mint sales figures do and do not reveal will find more in Reading Mint Bullion Coin Sales.

This article may contain partner links. They never influence what we write.